As a seasoned real estate appraiser, I’ve seen regulatory tides rise and fall—but what we’re witnessing now under FHFA Director Bill Pulte is a full-blown deregulatory wave with profound implications for everyone in the real estate ecosystem.
In a bold pivot from prior policy, Pulte recently rescinded a slew of Biden-era advisory bulletins, including the termination of Special Purpose Credit Programs (SPCPs) and the rollback of Unfair or Deceptive Acts or Practices (UDAP) enforcement directives for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. If you’re wondering what this means for appraisal practice, buckle up—we’re entering transformative territory.
SPCPs and UDAP: A Quick Refresher
SPCPs, authorized under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act since 1974, are targeted lending tools designed to help economically disadvantaged groups gain fair access to credit. Lenders could, under these programs, offer more flexible underwriting standards—think lower down payments or better rates—for borrowers historically excluded from homeownership opportunities.
UDAP, on the other hand, is a framework that targets practices deemed unfair, deceptive, or abusive. The rescinded bulletin directed GSEs to monitor consumer protection themselves—a role critics argued turned Fannie and Freddie into de facto compliance cops.
What’s Behind the Policy Rollback?
Director Pulte made it clear—this isn’t just a tweak. He’s undoing what he and the administration view as overreach. According to Bob Broeksmit, CEO of the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA):
“The November bulletin’s specific expectations for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to conduct consumer protection oversight of their customers wrongly established the GSEs as compliance regulators… and would have negatively impacted consumers and lenders through higher costs.”
The MBA praised the rollback, calling it a win for common-sense regulation. But for us appraisers, the ripple effects go deeper.
The Appraisal Industry at a Crossroads
Here’s why this matters for valuation professionals:
- Standardization Pressure May Decrease: With UDAP oversight rescinded, the pressure to conform appraisals to rigid consumer protection standards may ease—especially in loan origination contexts.
- Greater Role for Human Appraisers: With SPCPs gone, more lending decisions will revert to conventional underwriting—often requiring more comprehensive, nuanced appraisals rather than relying on automated models or relaxed criteria.
- Risk-Based Pricing Will Rise: Expect more scrutiny on appraisals in privatized loan environments. When GSEs are driven more by shareholder returns than social missions, the precision and defensibility of appraisals become paramount.
- Potential for Market Volatility: As Fannie and Freddie inch toward privatization, there’s an increased need for real-time, hyper-local market analysis—something algorithmic models still struggle to match. Cue: the indispensable appraiser.
Implications for Real Estate Consumers and Professionals
- Homebuyers might see stricter loan approvals. Without SPCPs, fewer flexibilities exist for first-time or disadvantaged borrowers.
- Sellers need more accurate valuations to avoid undercutting price or hitting appraisal issues mid-transaction.
- Investors and Agents should prepare for a market with more traditional credit standards and fewer government guarantees.
- Attorneys and CPAs navigating estate planning or asset valuations must now lean more heavily on defensible appraisal reports.
What’s Next for the GSEs?
All signs point to a gradual shift toward privatization. Pulte has already cleaned house at Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae—signaling a long-game restructuring of these housing behemoths.
While full privatization may not happen overnight, appraisers need to adapt now. The GSEs may move toward a model that demands more private capital participation, increased pricing risk, and reduced direct federal oversight. That changes the way loans are underwritten, priced, and—yes—appraised.
Final Thoughts: The Appraiser’s New Role in a Deregulated Market
In this deregulated, re-privatized future, appraisers aren’t just number crunchers—we’re market interpreters, risk analysts, and consumer educators. We ensure that the transition toward less oversight doesn’t mean less fairness or less accuracy.
Whether you’re a homeowner trying to refinance, a buyer navigating tighter credit, or an investor assessing your next move, a seasoned appraiser will be more essential than ever.
Stay sharp, stay informed—and remember, we’re not just valuing property. We’re redefining value.
📝 Like what you read? Subscribe to The Redefine Value Post for weekly insights and drop your thoughts in the comments below. We value your feedback—because real estate isn’t just about properties. It’s about people.